St. James' hidden gem serving birria, al pastor, and burritos with a 4.9-star reputation.
A food truck parked outside a Carvel on Middle Country Road might not sound like a culinary destination, but regulars on Long Island's North Shore know better. Taco Island Mexican Cantina has quietly earned a 4.9-star rating from over 140 customers, one order of birria tacos at a time, and that kind of loyalty doesn't come from a brick-and-mortar address.
The menu leans into the flavors that matter most: slow-braised meats, handmade salsas, and tortillas that hold up under the weight of generous fillings. The al pastor is bright and savory with just enough char, the barbacoa falls apart the way it should, and the burritos are packed like they mean it. Customers consistently note that food comes out exactly when promised, which in the food truck world is its own kind of superpower.
The crew behind the window is genuinely friendly, the kind of people who remember what you ordered last time. St. James, NY now has a taco spot that punches well above its parking lot address.
The menu at Taco Island is built around the cuts and preparations that make Mexican street food worth seeking out. Birria tacos lead the charge, slow-cooked beef folded into corn tortillas and served with a rich consommé for dipping. Al pastor, barbacoa, and other seasoned meats round out the taco lineup, and every order comes together fast without cutting corners on flavor.
Chalupas, burritos, and combo plates round out the menu for those who want something more substantial. The burritos in particular have earned their own fan base, stuffed thick and wrapped tight. Whether you're grabbing lunch on a weekday or making a dedicated trip from across the island, the portions are generous and the price point makes repeat visits an easy habit to form.
Take a look at our space and what we have to offer
Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers
Taco Island operates as a food truck at 680 Middle Country Rd in St. James, NY 11780. It is parked at the Carvel location, so look for the truck when you pull in.
The menu features birria tacos, al pastor, barbacoa, and chalupas among others. The birria tacos come with a consommé for dipping and are one of the most popular items.
Yes. Burritos are a fan favorite at Taco Island and customers frequently call them some of the best they have had on Long Island. They are generously stuffed with your choice of seasoned meat.
Customers consistently report that the food is ready when the staff says it will be. Wait times are reasonable for a food truck, and the crew communicates clearly about timing.
For current hours and days of operation, check the website at birriatacosstjames.com or look them up on Google Maps for the most up-to-date schedule before making a trip.
Payment options are best confirmed directly with the truck. Visit birriatacosstjames.com or check their Google listing for current payment information.
The combination of traditional birria preparation, consistently great al pastor, and a crew that genuinely cares about every order has earned Taco Island a 4.9-star rating from over 140 reviews, which speaks for itself.
Hand-picked local businesses near here, surfaced by NearByMeNow. Click any card to explore the full directory.
120 Edgewood Ave, Smithtown, NY 11787, USA
1455 Veterans Memorial Hwy, Islandia, NY 11749, USA
41 Horseblock Rd, Centereach, NY 11720, USA
39 Nassau Ave, Islip, NY 11751, USA
14 A Oak St, Patchogue, NY 11772, USA